The Google Pixel 3 and Apple iPhone XS are two flagship smartphones from 2018 that still get compared today. The Pixel 3 excels at computational photography and offers a cleaner Android experience, while the iPhone XS delivers a more polished ecosystem, longer software support, and better video recording. This article breaks down the differences in design, performance, camera, battery, and software to help you decide which used phone fits your needs.
Design and Build
The Pixel 3 uses an aluminum frame with a matte glass back, available in Just Black, Clearly White, and Not Pink. It has a single 12.2MP rear camera and a distinctive two-tone finish. The iPhone XS uses a stainless steel frame with a glossy glass back, available in Gold, Space Gray, and Silver. It has a dual 12MP rear camera system. Both phones have IP68 water resistance, but the iPhone XS is rated for deeper submersion (2 meters for 30 minutes vs. 1.5 meters for the Pixel). The Pixel 3 is slightly lighter at 148g vs. 177g, and its smaller 5.5-inch display makes it easier to handle than the 5.8-inch iPhone.
Display and Media
The Pixel 3 has a 5.5-inch OLED display at 443 ppi, while the iPhone XS has a 5.8-inch Super Retina OLED at 458 ppi. Both are sharp and vibrant, but the iPhone supports HDR10 and Dolby Vision, which makes it better for streaming high-dynamic-range content on Netflix or YouTube. The Pixel 3 supports HDR but not Dolby Vision. The iPhone also has stereo speakers that are slightly louder and more balanced. For media consumption, the iPhone XS is the better choice if you watch a lot of HDR video.
Performance and Software
The iPhone XS uses the A12 Bionic chip, which was Apple’s fastest at the time and still holds up well today. The Pixel 3 uses the Snapdragon 845, a flagship Android chip from the same era. In benchmarks, the A12 outperforms the Snapdragon 845 by a significant margin, especially in GPU-intensive tasks. However, the Pixel 3 runs stock Android 9 Pie, which is clean and fast. The iPhone XS runs iOS 12. In terms of software updates, Apple supports iPhones for 5-6 years, while Google promised 3 years of OS updates for the Pixel 3 (ending in 2021). If you’re buying a used phone in 2024, the iPhone XS will still receive iOS 17 updates, but the Pixel 3 is stuck on Android 12. For long-term software support, the iPhone is the clear winner.
Camera Capabilities
The Pixel 3 is famous for its single-camera computational photography. It uses HDR+ and Night Sight to produce stunning photos, especially in low light. The iPhone XS has a dual camera (wide and telephoto) that offers 2x optical zoom and a portrait mode with adjustable depth of field. Both take excellent photos, but the Pixel 3 is generally considered better for still photography, particularly in low light and for astrophotography (with a tripod). The iPhone XS is better for video: it records 4K at up to 60fps with excellent stabilization, while the Pixel 3 is limited to 4K at 30fps. If you prioritize photography, the Pixel 3 is a bargain; if you shoot video, the iPhone XS is superior.
Battery and Charging
The Pixel 3 has a 2915mAh battery, while the iPhone XS has a 2658mAh. Despite the smaller battery, the iPhone XS often gets similar or better battery life due to the efficiency of the A12 chip and iOS optimization. Both phones support fast charging (18W for Pixel, 18W for iPhone) and wireless charging. The Pixel 3 supports 10W wireless charging with the Pixel Stand, while the iPhone XS supports 7.5W Qi charging. In real-world usage, expect a full day of moderate use on both, but heavy users may need a top-up by evening.
Storage and Price
The Pixel 3 comes in 64GB and 128GB storage options, while the iPhone XS comes in 64GB, 256GB, and 512GB. Neither supports expandable storage. In the used market (as of 2024), the Pixel 3 is significantly cheaper, often under $100, while the iPhone XS is around $150-$250 depending on condition. If you’re on a tight budget and want a great camera, the Pixel 3 is a steal. If you need more storage or plan to keep the phone for several more years, the iPhone XS is worth the premium.
Common Problems and Considerations
Both phones have known issues. The Pixel 3 has had reports of random reboots, speaker distortion at high volumes, and battery drain after updates. The iPhone XS has had issues with weak cellular reception (due to the Intel modem) and some users report battery health degradation faster than expected. Before buying used, check the battery health on the iPhone (Settings > Battery > Battery Health) and ask the seller about any software issues on the Pixel. Also, note that the Pixel 3 no longer receives security updates, so it’s not ideal for banking or sensitive data.
How to Choose
To decide between the two, consider your priorities:
- If you want the best still camera for the lowest price, choose the Pixel 3.
- If you want long-term software updates, better video, and a more polished ecosystem, choose the iPhone XS.
- If you prefer Android’s flexibility and customization, the Pixel 3 is the way to go.
- If you’re already invested in Apple’s ecosystem (AirDrop, iMessage, Apple Watch), the iPhone XS is the logical choice.
For most people in 2024, the iPhone XS is the safer recommendation because of its continued software support and better performance. However, if you’re a photography enthusiast on a budget, the Pixel 3’s camera is still remarkable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which phone has a better camera?
The Pixel 3 takes better still photos, especially in low light, thanks to Night Sight. The iPhone XS is better for video and offers optical zoom.
Are both phones 5G capable?
No, neither the Pixel 3 nor the iPhone XS supports 5G. They are 4G LTE phones.
Can I still get repairs for these phones?
Google no longer sells the Pixel 3, but third-party repair shops may have parts. Apple still supports the iPhone XS with official battery and screen replacements for a fee.
Which phone is better for gaming?
The iPhone XS is better for gaming due to its faster A12 chip and better GPU performance. The Pixel 3 can handle most games but may struggle with the most demanding titles.
Do these phones have headphone jacks?
No, both phones lack a 3.5mm headphone jack. You’ll need wireless headphones or a USB-C to 3.5mm adapter.
Related
General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this bed
- Show User Library in macOS High Sierra & Sierra
- Device Manager Shortcut: Windows 10 Desktop
- How to Remove Forgotten Passcode from iPhone
- Fix Slow Wi-Fi Problem iPhone X: 9 Steps
- How to Check if a Candidate Accepts Crypto Donations
- How to Listen to Deleted Voicemails on iPhone