The HTC Droid Incredible 2 and the Apple iPhone (specifically the iPhone 4, its direct contemporary) differ fundamentally in operating system, design philosophy, and carrier availability: the Incredible 2 runs Android 2.2 on Verizon’s network with a removable battery and expandable storage, while the iPhone 4 runs iOS 4 with a sealed battery and no memory card slot. For most buyers in 2011, the choice came down to preferring Android’s customization and Verizon’s coverage versus Apple’s polished app ecosystem and simpler user experience. Here is a detailed comparison of the two phones that were often pitted against each other.
Background and Release Context
The HTC Droid Incredible 2 was released in April 2011 as a Verizon Wireless exclusive, succeeding the original Droid Incredible. It was part of Verizon’s “Droid” branding campaign that marketed Android phones as functional alternatives to the iPhone. The phone ran Android 2.2 (Froyo) with HTC’s Sense UI skin, and was later updated to Android 2.3 (Gingerbread).
The Apple iPhone 4, released in June 2010, was the fourth-generation iPhone and the first to feature a front-facing camera and Retina display. It was available on multiple carriers worldwide, but in the United States it was exclusive to AT&T until February 2011, when a Verizon version launched. That Verizon iPhone 4 was the direct competitor to the Incredible 2.
Both phones represented the peak of smartphone technology in early 2011: dual-core processors were just emerging, 4G LTE was not yet mainstream, and the app stores were growing rapidly. Understanding the differences requires looking at hardware, software, and the user experience each offered.
Hardware and Design
The two phones took very different approaches to physical design and internal components.
- Display: The Incredible 2 had a 4.0-inch Super LCD (SLCD) display with a resolution of 480×800 pixels (WVGA). The iPhone 4 had a 3.5-inch Retina display with a resolution of 640×960 pixels, which was significantly sharper. The iPhone’s pixel density was 326 ppi versus the Incredible 2’s 233 ppi.
- Processor and RAM: The Incredible 2 used a 1 GHz single-core Snapdragon processor with 768 MB of RAM. The iPhone 4 used Apple’s A4 chip (also 1 GHz single-core) with 512 MB of RAM. In real-world use, the iPhone often felt smoother due to tighter hardware-software integration.
- Storage: The Incredible 2 came with 1 GB of internal storage (about 748 MB available to the user) but supported microSD cards up to 32 GB, allowing users to add storage cheaply. The iPhone 4 came in 8, 16, or 32 GB fixed capacities with no expansion slot.
- Battery: The Incredible 2 had a 1450 mAh removable battery. The iPhone 4 had a 1420 mAh non-removable battery. The Incredible 2’s battery could be swapped for a spare or a higher-capacity extended battery, a major advantage for heavy users.
- Build: The iPhone 4 featured a glass front and back with a stainless steel frame, which was praised for its premium feel but was also prone to shattering when dropped. The Incredible 2 used a plastic body with a textured soft-touch back, which was more durable but felt less premium.
- Camera: Both had an 8-megapixel rear camera with autofocus and LED flash. The iPhone 4 added a front-facing VGA camera for FaceTime video calls; the Incredible 2 also had a front-facing VGA camera but video calling was limited to apps like Skype or Google Talk, as Verizon’s video calling service was not widely used.
Operating System and Software
The most significant difference was the operating system: Android 2.2/2.3 on the Incredible 2 versus iOS 4 on the iPhone 4.
Android (HTC Sense): Android offered deep customization: users could add widgets to home screens, change default apps (e.g., set a third-party browser as default), and install apps from sources other than the official market. HTC’s Sense UI added a custom launcher, weather animations, and social media integration. However, Android 2.2 had fewer polished apps than iOS, and the operating system was more prone to fragmentation and occasional lag.
iOS: iOS was more locked down but also more consistent. The home screen was a grid of icons with no widgets (until iOS 14 in 2020). Users could not change default apps for basic functions like email or browser. However, iOS had a more mature app store with higher-quality apps and games, and Apple provided regular software updates for older devices for several years. The iPhone 4 received iOS updates up to iOS 7.1.2 in 2014, while the Incredible 2’s official updates ended with Android 2.3 (though unofficial ROMs existed).
Carrier and Network
In the United States, the Incredible 2 was exclusively on Verizon Wireless, which was known for its extensive coverage, especially in rural areas. The iPhone 4 was available on AT&T (since 2010) and Verizon (since February 2011). AT&T had faster HSPA+ data speeds in many cities, but Verizon’s 3G CDMA network had broader coverage. Neither phone supported LTE; the iPhone 4 used GSM/HSPA on AT&T and CDMA/EV-DO on Verizon, while the Incredible 2 used CDMA/EV-DO only.
This meant that the Incredible 2 could not be used internationally with a local SIM card (unless it was the rare global version), while the AT&T iPhone 4 could be unlocked and used with foreign GSM networks. The Verizon iPhone 4 was also CDMA-only, but later iOS updates added a world mode for some models.
Common Problems and Issues
Both phones had known issues that users complained about.
- HTC Droid Incredible 2: Users reported random reboots, poor battery life (especially with 4G apps), and a camera that could be slow to launch. The phone also suffered from “ghost touches” (phantom screen presses) for some users. Because it was a Verizon exclusive, it was not eligible for updates through other carriers, and HTC was slow to push Android 2.3 updates.
- iPhone 4: The most famous issue was the “Antennagate” problem, where holding the phone in a certain way (covering the lower-left gap) caused signal loss. Apple offered free bumpers or a software fix that displayed more accurate signal bars. The glass back cracked easily, and the battery was non-replaceable, requiring a trip to Apple for replacement.
How to Choose Between Them
If you were deciding between these two phones in 2011, consider the following factors:
- Operating system preference: Do you want to customize widgets and default apps? Choose the Incredible 2. Do you prefer a simple, consistent interface? Choose the iPhone 4.
- Carrier coverage: If you needed Verizon’s coverage, the Incredible 2 was a strong choice, but the Verizon iPhone 4 also existed. If you were on AT&T, the iPhone 4 was the obvious pick.
- Storage needs: If you wanted to store lots of music or videos, the Incredible 2’s microSD slot was a huge advantage. The iPhone 4’s fixed storage meant you had to pay more upfront for a 32 GB model.
- Battery life: The Incredible 2’s removable battery allowed you to carry a spare. The iPhone 4’s battery lasted about the same (around 6-7 hours of talk time) but could not be replaced by the user.
- App ecosystem: iOS had a larger selection of high-quality apps, especially games and productivity tools. Android’s Market (now Google Play) was growing but had more low-quality apps.
- Long-term updates: Apple supported the iPhone 4 for four years, while HTC’s support for the Incredible 2 was limited to about one major update. If you planned to keep the phone for more than two years, the iPhone was a better bet.
Cost and Value in 2011
Both phones were priced at $199.99 with a two-year contract at launch. The Incredible 2 was often discounted to $99 or even free with a new contract within months. The iPhone 4 remained at $199 for the 16 GB model and $299 for 32 GB. Off-contract, the iPhone 4 cost $599-$699, while the Incredible 2 was around $499. Over time, the iPhone held its resale value better due to brand demand.
However, the total cost of ownership could differ: the Incredible 2’s expandable storage meant you could buy a 16 GB microSD card for about $20, while upgrading an iPhone 4 from 16 GB to 32 GB at purchase cost $100. The iPhone 4’s non-removable battery meant a replacement (if needed) cost about $50-80, while a spare battery for the Incredible 2 cost around $15.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which phone had better battery life?
In real-world usage, both phones lasted about the same—roughly a full day of moderate use. The Incredible 2’s larger screen and Android background processes could drain the battery faster, but the removable battery allowed users to swap in a fresh one. The iPhone 4’s battery was more efficient due to the Retina display’s lower power consumption when showing static content, but once it degraded, you had to pay for a replacement.
Can the HTC Droid Incredible 2 be updated to a newer Android version?
Officially, the Incredible 2 was updated to Android 2.3 (Gingerbread) only. However, the developer community created custom ROMs based on Android 4.0 (Ice Cream Sandwich) and even 4.4 (KitKat), but these were unofficial, required unlocking the bootloader, and could be unstable. Most users stuck with the official version.
Is the iPhone 4 still usable today?
Technically yes, but not as a daily driver. The iPhone 4 cannot run modern iOS versions (it tops out at iOS 7.1.2), and many current apps require iOS 12 or later, so the App Store will not let you download them. The phone can still make calls, send texts, and browse the web with older browsers, but performance is slow and many websites will not render properly. The Incredible 2 is similarly outdated.
Which phone had a better camera?
Both had 8-megapixel rear cameras, but the iPhone 4’s camera was generally considered superior in color accuracy and low-light performance, thanks to Apple’s image processing. The Incredible 2’s camera was good but had more noise in dim conditions. The front cameras were both VGA (0.3 MP), so video calls were low-resolution.
Can I use the Droid Incredible 2 on a modern carrier?
No. The Incredible 2 only supports CDMA (2G/3G) on Verizon’s network, which has been shut down for 3G (Verizon retired its CDMA network in December 2022). The phone cannot be activated on any current US carrier. The iPhone 4 (AT&T version) also lacks LTE and VoLTE, so it cannot make calls on modern networks either.
Related
General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this bed
- Spotify Jam Not Working on Mobile? Fixes That Work
- Windows 10 No Internet Secured WiFi Error Fix
- Multi-Cloud GPU Failover Design Guide
- Error Code Currant Destiny? Meaning & Fixes
- Install Windows After Replacing Hard Drive
- AirPlay with Roku Multi-Device Setup: A How-To