sodcalculator

10 Tech How-To

Microsoft Authenticator vs Authy: Which Is Better?

Guide 10-45078 · Updated · Step by step

Microsoft Authenticator and Authy are both free two-factor authentication (2FA) apps, but they differ mainly in backup, multi-device support, and platform integration. Microsoft Authenticator is best if you live in the Microsoft ecosystem, while Authy is better for cross-platform users who want encrypted cloud backups and desktop access.

Background: Why You Need a 2FA App

Passwords alone are no longer enough. Data breaches expose millions of credentials every year, and people reuse passwords across sites. Two-factor authentication adds a second check: something you know (your password) plus something you have (your phone). Authenticator apps generate time-based one-time passwords (TOTP) that change every 30 seconds, so a stolen password is useless without the current code.

Both Microsoft Authenticator and Authy are free, open about their security, and available on iOS and Android. They replace the older SMS codes, which can be intercepted via SIM swapping. The key differences lie in how they handle backups, multi-device sync, and account recovery.

How Microsoft Authenticator Works

Microsoft Authenticator is designed to work seamlessly with Microsoft accounts (Outlook, Xbox, Azure, Office 365). It supports push notifications for Microsoft logins—you just tap “Approve” instead of typing a code. For other sites, it generates standard TOTP codes.

Its backup feature uses your personal Microsoft account to encrypt and sync your credentials to the cloud. This means if you lose your phone, you can restore your codes on a new device by signing into the same Microsoft account. However, the backup is tied to that account, and the recovery process can be confusing if you don’t remember your account details.

How Authy Works

Authy, made by Twilio, is a standalone 2FA app that works across many platforms: iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, and even Linux (via a desktop app). It also offers browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox. This makes Authy a strong choice for people who want to log into their accounts from a computer without pulling out their phone.

Authy’s standout feature is its encrypted cloud backup. Your 2FA codes are encrypted with a password you set, and they sync across all your devices automatically. If you lose your phone, you can install Authy on a new phone and restore your codes with your backup password. This is a major advantage over many other authenticator apps that lock you out if you lose your device.

Key Differences: Backup and Multi-Device

The biggest practical difference is how each app handles your codes when you switch phones.

  • Microsoft Authenticator: Backs up to your Microsoft account, but only if you enable it. Restoring requires you to verify your identity with the Microsoft account. It does not offer a desktop app or browser extension.
  • Authy: Backs up to Authy’s cloud with a separate encryption password. You can install Authy on multiple devices, including desktop, and they all stay in sync. If you lose your phone, you can still access your codes from your computer.

For multi-device users, Authy is clearly more flexible. For Microsoft-centric users, Authenticator’s push notifications are more convenient than typing a code.

Security and Account Recovery

Both apps are secure, but they have different recovery models.

Microsoft Authenticator’s backup is encrypted with your Microsoft account credentials. If you forget that password, you could lose access to your 2FA codes. Authy’s backup is encrypted with a password you create specifically for Authy. If you forget that password, you cannot restore your codes. Neither app can reset that password for you—that’s the price of security.

One common misconception is that Authy is less secure because it stores codes in the cloud. In reality, Authy encrypts your data with AES-256 and uses a master password that only you know. The cloud backup is a convenience, not a vulnerability. However, if someone obtains your Authy backup password and your phone number, they could potentially access your codes—so choose a strong, unique password.

Ease of Use and Setup

Both apps are easy to set up. You scan a QR code from a website, and the app adds the account. The main difference is in daily use.

  • Microsoft Authenticator: Push notifications for Microsoft accounts mean you don’t even need to open the app. For non-Microsoft sites, you open the app and read the code.
  • Authy: You can approve login requests from the desktop app or browser extension, which is handy if you’re working on a computer. The mobile app also shows a searchable list of your accounts.

Authy has a slight edge in organization: it lets you group accounts and search them. Microsoft Authenticator is simpler, but it can get cluttered if you have many accounts.

How to Choose Between Them

Your choice depends on your priorities:

  • Choose Microsoft Authenticator if you use Microsoft services heavily (Outlook, Office 365, Azure) and want push notifications for those logins.
  • Choose Authy if you want cross-platform access, cloud backup that isn’t tied to a specific email provider, or the ability to use 2FA on your desktop.
  • If you switch phones often, Authy’s multi-device sync makes the transition seamless. Microsoft Authenticator’s backup is reliable but requires you to re-verify your Microsoft account.

If you’re still undecided, you can use both—many people do. Some use Authy for personal accounts and Microsoft Authenticator for work accounts, especially if their employer requires it.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

One frequent issue with Microsoft Authenticator is that users don’t enable backup before they lose their phone. Then they’re locked out of their accounts. To avoid this, enable backup in the app’s settings and write down your Microsoft account password.

Another misconception is that Authy is only for Twilio customers. It’s not—anyone can use it for any TOTP-based 2FA. Also, some people worry that Authy’s cloud backup is a security risk, but it’s encrypted and widely used.

If you’re moving from one app to the other, you’ll need to re-scan each QR code. There’s no way to transfer codes between apps directly. So take your time and do it one account at a time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use both Microsoft Authenticator and Authy at the same time?

Yes, you can have the same account (like Gmail) in both apps. When you scan a QR code, you can add it to multiple authenticator apps. This is useful as a backup if you lose one phone.

Which app is more secure?

Both are equally secure in terms of encryption and TOTP generation. The main difference is recovery: Authy’s backup is protected by a password you choose, while Microsoft Authenticator’s backup is tied to your Microsoft account. Neither is inherently more secure, but Authy’s multi-device sync can be a risk if your backup password is weak.

What happens if I lose my phone?

With Authy, you can install the app on a new phone and restore your codes with your backup password. With Microsoft Authenticator, you can restore from your Microsoft account backup, but you’ll need to verify your identity. If you didn’t enable backup, you’ll have to reset each account individually.

Can I use these apps for my work accounts?

Yes, most work accounts (like Office 365, Google Workspace, and Salesforce) support TOTP codes. Some employers may require a specific app, but generally both work. Microsoft Authenticator offers push notifications for Azure AD accounts, which is a plus for enterprise users.

Do these apps work without an internet connection?

Yes, both apps generate TOTP codes locally on your device, so they work offline. The codes are based on time, not internet access. However, push notifications (in Microsoft Authenticator) require an internet connection.

Is Authy really free?

Yes, Authy is free for personal use. There’s no premium tier. Microsoft Authenticator is also free. Both apps are supported by their parent companies (Microsoft and Twilio) and don’t show ads.

Related

General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.

More in this bed

The whole Tech How-To bed →