sodcalculator

10 Tech How-To

Microsoft Planner vs Trello: Key Differences

Guide 10-52102 · Updated · Step by step

Microsoft Planner and Trello are both popular project management tools, but they serve different needs: Planner is built for teams already using Microsoft 365, offering tight integration with Outlook, Teams, and SharePoint, while Trello is a standalone, visually-driven Kanban board tool known for its simplicity and flexibility. This article breaks down their core differences in features, pricing, integrations, and use cases to help you choose the right one.

Background: How Each Tool Evolved

Microsoft Planner launched in 2016 as part of the Microsoft 365 (then Office 365) suite, aimed at providing a lightweight, team-based task management solution for businesses already using Microsoft’s ecosystem. It was designed to complement heavier tools like Microsoft Project, focusing on simple Kanban boards and integration with Outlook and Teams.

Trello, founded in 2011 and acquired by Atlassian in 2017, started as a standalone Kanban board app inspired by the Toyota Production System’s visual workflow. It gained popularity for its intuitive, card-based interface and its “power-ups” (integrations) that allow users to customize boards without coding. Today, Trello is used by individuals, startups, and enterprises alike, often as a lightweight alternative to more complex project management software.

Core Interface and Workflow

Both tools use a Kanban board layout, but they differ in how they structure work.

  • Planner: Boards are called “plans.” Each plan has buckets (lists) and tasks (cards). Tasks can have checklists, labels, due dates, and attachments. You can assign tasks to team members, and each task has a comments section. The interface is clean but feels more “business-like” and integrated with Microsoft’s design language.
  • Trello: Boards are the top-level container. Within a board, you have lists (columns) and cards. Cards can have checklists, labels, due dates, attachments, and comments. Trello’s interface is more playful, with a wider range of customization options, including custom fields, card covers, and a more extensive power-up ecosystem.

For a team that wants a simple, no-frills Kanban experience, both work well. However, Trello offers more visual customization (e.g., changing card colors, adding cover images), while Planner keeps a more uniform, corporate look.

Integration with Microsoft 365 vs. Third-Party Apps

This is the biggest differentiator.

Microsoft Planner: Since it’s part of Microsoft 365, Planner integrates natively with:

  • Microsoft Teams: You can add a Planner tab to a Teams channel, allowing team members to view and edit the same board without leaving Teams.
  • Outlook: Tasks appear in Outlook’s To-Do list and can be synced with your calendar.
  • SharePoint: Each plan is backed by a SharePoint site, so you get file storage and version history.
  • Power Automate: You can create automated workflows (e.g., when a task is completed, send an email).

Trello: Trello does not have native Microsoft 365 integration, but it offers a wide range of “Power-Ups” (integrations) that connect to apps like Slack, Google Drive, Dropbox, and even Microsoft Teams (via a third-party power-up). However, many of these require a paid plan, and the setup is more manual.

Pricing and Plans

Both tools offer free tiers, but the paid plans differ significantly.

  • Microsoft Planner: Included with most Microsoft 365 business and enterprise plans (e.g., Business Basic, Business Standard, E3, E5). There is no standalone paid version; you must buy a Microsoft 365 subscription. The free tier is limited to a trial of Microsoft 365.
  • Trello: Offers a free plan with unlimited cards and members, but limits you to 10 boards and 1 MB file attachments. Paid plans (Standard, Premium, Enterprise) cost per user per month and unlock unlimited boards, larger attachments, advanced checklists, custom fields, and more power-ups.

If your organization already uses Microsoft 365, Planner is effectively free. Trello’s free plan is great for individuals or small teams, but the cost can add up as you scale.

Collaboration and Permissions

Both tools allow real-time collaboration, but the permission models differ.

Planner: Uses Microsoft 365 groups. You add members to a group, and they can access all plans within that group. Permissions are tied to the group’s SharePoint site, so you can control read/write access at the site level. This is familiar to IT admins but can be restrictive for external collaborators (guests) unless you configure external sharing.

Trello: Boards can be shared with individuals or teams. You can invite guests (free for up to 10 guests per board on the free plan) and set permissions (admin, normal, observer). Trello is more flexible for working with external clients or freelancers, as you can add them with just an email address.

Common Problems and Limitations

No tool is perfect; here are common complaints:

  • Planner: Limited customization (no custom fields, no card covers), no built-in time tracking, and the mobile app is less polished than Trello’s. Also, the board view is the only view; you can’t switch to a list or calendar view (though Microsoft is rolling out new views in 2024).
  • Trello: The free plan is limited to 10 boards, which can be restrictive for managing multiple projects. Power-ups are capped at 1 per board on the free plan. Also, the card layout can become cluttered with too many labels and checklists.

How to Choose: Which One Is Right for You?

Consider these factors:

  • If your team already uses Microsoft 365: Choose Planner for seamless integration with Outlook, Teams, and SharePoint. You won’t need to manage separate logins or data silos.
  • If you need a simple, visual tool for personal or small-team use: Trello’s free plan is excellent for getting started quickly, especially if you want to use it outside of a corporate environment.
  • If you need advanced features like time tracking, custom fields, or extensive integrations: Trello’s paid plans offer more flexibility, but you’ll pay per user. Planner’s features are more limited but are included in your existing subscription.
  • If you work with external clients or freelancers: Trello’s guest access is easier to manage than Planner’s Microsoft 365 group permissions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I migrate from Planner to Trello or vice versa?

Yes, you can migrate manually by exporting tasks (Planner allows export to Excel; Trello allows export to JSON or CSV) and then importing into the other tool. However, attachments and comments may not transfer cleanly. Third-party migration tools exist but often require paid plans.

Can I use Planner without a Microsoft 365 subscription?

No, Planner is only available as part of a Microsoft 365 plan. There is no standalone free version. You can sign up for a free trial of Microsoft 365, but after that, you’ll need a paid subscription.

Which tool is better for large enterprise teams?

It depends on your existing infrastructure. If your enterprise already uses Microsoft 365, Planner is easier to adopt and manage. Trello Enterprise offers more customization and scalability, but you’ll need to integrate it with your existing tools.

Does Trello have a calendar view?

Yes, Trello has a calendar view power-up that is available on all paid plans. The free plan includes a limited calendar view (only shows cards with due dates) but it’s not as full-featured.

Can I assign tasks to multiple people in Planner or Trello?

In Planner, you can assign a task to only one person. In Trello, you can add multiple members to a card, but only one can be the “assignee” if you use the default fields. However, you can use custom fields or labels to track multiple assignees.

Related

General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.

More in this bed

The whole Tech How-To bed →