sodcalculator

10 Tech How-To

Fix Failed Seagate External Hard Drive

Guide 10-57415 · Updated · Step by step

If your Seagate external hard drive is not recognized, making clicking sounds, or showing as unallocated, the fix usually involves checking the cable and port, updating drivers, or using Seagate’s own diagnostic tool. This guide walks you through the most common causes and step-by-step solutions before you consider data recovery or replacement.

Why External Drives Fail

External hard drives are essentially the same as internal drives but wrapped in an enclosure with a USB bridge board. That extra layer introduces several failure points that internal drives don’t have. The most common reasons a Seagate external drive stops working are:

  • Power issues – Some drives need more power than a single USB port provides, especially older 3.5″ desktop drives.
  • Bad cable or port – USB cables degrade, and ports can fail or provide inconsistent power.
  • Driver conflicts – Windows or macOS may fail to recognize the drive after an update.
  • File system corruption – Sudden ejection or power loss can corrupt the file system, making the drive unreadable.
  • Physical damage – Dropping the drive or exposing it to heat/moisture can cause mechanical or electronic failure.
  • Firmware issues – Occasionally, the drive’s firmware becomes corrupted, causing it to not spin up or be detected.

First Steps: Check the Basics

Before you panic, try these simple checks. Many “failed” drives are just suffering from a loose connection or a tired USB port.

  1. Try a different USB port – Use a port directly on the computer (not a hub). If you have a desktop, try a port on the back.
  2. Swap the cable – Use the original cable if possible, or a known-good one. For drives with a detachable cable, this is easy. For those with a built-in cable, try a USB Y-cable (two USB ends) to get more power.
  3. Try another computer – This tells you if the problem is the drive or your system.
  4. Listen and feel – Does the drive spin up? You should feel a slight vibration. If it clicks repeatedly or is silent, it’s likely a mechanical or power issue.
  5. Check Disk Management (Windows) or Disk Utility (macOS) – Even if the drive doesn’t show in File Explorer or Finder, it may appear in these tools. If it shows as “Unallocated” or “Not Initialized,” the drive is being detected but the file system is missing or damaged.

Using Seagate’s Diagnostic Tools

Seagate provides free diagnostic software called SeaTools for Windows and SeaTools for Mac. These tools can test the drive’s health and often fix certain errors.

  1. Download SeaTools from Seagate’s official website.
  2. Install and run the software.
  3. Select your Seagate drive from the list.
  4. Run a Short Drive Self Test (DST) first. This checks the basic functionality.
  5. If the short test passes, run a Long Generic Test – this scans the entire disk surface for bad sectors.
  6. If the test fails, note the error code. Seagate’s website has a list of error codes and what they mean.

If SeaTools reports a failure, the drive is physically failing and should not be used for critical data. If it passes, the issue is likely software-related, and you can proceed to the next steps.

Updating Drivers and Reinstalling the Device

Sometimes the issue is that Windows or macOS has a corrupted driver entry for the drive. Reinstalling the driver can fix detection issues.

On Windows:

  1. Open Device Manager (right-click the Start button and select it).
  2. Expand Disk drives. You should see your Seagate drive. If it has a yellow exclamation mark, there’s a problem.
  3. Right-click the drive and select Uninstall device. Do not check “Delete the driver software for this device” unless you have the driver downloaded.
  4. Unplug the drive, restart your computer, then plug the drive back in. Windows will reinstall the driver.

On macOS:

  1. Open Disk Utility (in Applications/Utilities).
  2. If the drive appears in the sidebar but is grayed out, try First Aid on the drive.
  3. If it doesn’t appear, reset the NVRAM (on Intel Macs) or SMC. For Apple Silicon Macs, the process is different – you may need to reinstall macOS if the drive doesn’t show up.

Data Recovery Options

If the drive is making clicking sounds, is not spinning up, or SeaTools fails, the data is at risk. The most important rule: do not keep trying to force the drive to work – this can cause further damage.

  • Software recovery – If the drive is recognized but unreadable, tools like Recuva, TestDisk, or EaseUS Data Recovery Wizard can sometimes recover files. These work best if the file system is corrupted but the disk is physically healthy.
  • Professional recovery – If the drive has mechanical issues, you need a cleanroom service. This is expensive (hundreds to thousands of dollars), but it’s the only way to get data off a physically failing drive. Seagate offers a data recovery service, but there are also independent labs.
  • DIY freezer trick – NOT recommended – There’s an old myth that freezing a hard drive helps. This can cause condensation and further damage. Avoid it.

Prevention and Long-Term Care

Once you’ve fixed your drive (or if you’ve replaced it), here’s how to avoid future failures:

  • Always eject properly – Use “Safely Remove Hardware” on Windows or drag to Trash on macOS.
  • Use a surge protector – Power surges can kill electronics.
  • Keep it cool and dry – Don’t leave it in a hot car or near a heater.
  • Back up your data – The 3-2-1 rule: three copies of your data, on two different media, with one offsite.
  • Check health regularly – Run SeaTools or a SMART check every few months.

When to Replace the Drive

If your Seagate drive is out of warranty and fails diagnostics, it’s usually cheaper to replace it than to repair it. External drives are relatively inexpensive. However, if the drive contains irreplaceable data, professional recovery is worth the cost.

When buying a replacement, consider:

  • Type – HDD (traditional) vs. SSD (solid state). SSDs are faster and more durable but more expensive per GB.
  • Capacity – Get at least double the space you currently use.
  • Interface – USB 3.0 or later for speed. USB-C is becoming standard.
  • Portability – 2.5″ drives are portable and bus-powered; 3.5″ drives need an AC adapter.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my Seagate external hard drive not showing up?

This is usually a connection issue (cable, port, or power) or a driver problem. Try a different cable and port, then check Disk Management/diskutil to see if the drive is detected at all. If it shows there but not in File Explorer/Finder, you may need to assign a drive letter or mount it.

Can I recover data from a clicking Seagate drive?

Clicking usually indicates a mechanical failure – the read/write head is failing. Do not attempt to run recovery software on it, as it can worsen the damage. Professional data recovery services have specialized equipment to handle this, but it’s expensive.

How do I fix a Seagate drive that needs initialization?

If the drive shows as “Not Initialized” in Disk Management, you can initialize it (GPT or MBR) and create a new partition. This will erase all data, so only do this if you don’t need the data or have a backup. After initializing, format the drive with NTFS (Windows) or exFAT (for cross-platform use).

Is it safe to use a Seagate drive that failed SeaTools?

No. If SeaTools reports a failure, the drive is unreliable and may fail completely at any time. Do not store important data on it. If you must use it temporarily, back up everything immediately and replace it as soon as possible.

Why does my Seagate drive work on one computer but not another?

This could be a power issue (the second computer’s USB port doesn’t provide enough power), a driver issue, or a file system compatibility issue (e.g., a drive formatted as NTFS won’t natively work on macOS without third-party software).

What does the Seagate warranty cover?

Seagate offers a limited warranty on their drives, typically 1-3 years depending on the model. It covers manufacturing defects, not data recovery. If your drive is under warranty and fails, you can get a replacement, but you’ll lose your data. Always back up.

Related

General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.

More in this bed

The whole Tech How-To bed →