sodcalculator

10 Tech How-To

How to Measure ROI of Custom Software for Employee Workflows

Guide 10-53998 · Updated · Step by step

This guide walks you through calculating the return on investment (ROI) of custom software built to streamline employee workflows. You’ll learn how to quantify both the costs and the benefits—time saved, error reduction, and productivity gains—so you can present a clear, numbers-based case to stakeholders. Before you start, you’ll need a few data points and a basic understanding of your current processes.

What You’ll Need

  • Baseline metrics of current workflow: average time per task, error rates, and employee output (from time tracking, CRM, or manual logs).
  • Cost data for the custom software: development, licensing, hosting, maintenance, and internal support hours.
  • Employee salary or billing rate data (at least an average) to convert time savings into monetary value.
  • Access to a spreadsheet or calculator for the arithmetic.

Step-by-Step

  1. Define the workflow and its scope. Pick one specific workflow (e.g., invoice processing, customer onboarding) that the custom software will replace or improve. Write down the start and end points, and list every manual step involved.
  2. Measure the current baseline. For each step, record the average time it takes (in minutes) and how often the workflow runs per week or month. Use time logs, observations, or estimates from team leads. Also note the current error rate—for example, how many invoices have mistakes that require rework.
  3. Estimate the post-implementation time. Based on the software’s expected features (e.g., auto-filling fields, automated approvals), estimate the new time per step. Be conservative—use a 20-30% reduction if you’re unsure, rather than assuming 90% automation.
  4. Calculate time savings per month. Use the formula: (Current time per workflow × frequency) − (New time per workflow × frequency) = monthly hours saved. For example, if a workflow takes 30 minutes and runs 100 times a month, that’s 50 hours. If the new time is 15 minutes, you save 25 hours per month.
  5. Convert time to money. Multiply the monthly hours saved by the fully loaded hourly cost of the employees doing the work (salary + benefits + overhead). For a $60,000/year employee, that’s roughly $30/hour, so 25 hours saved = $750/month.
  6. Add error-reduction savings. Estimate how many errors the software prevents per month (based on baseline error rate) and the cost to fix each error (time × hourly rate). For example, 10 errors/month at 1 hour each to fix = 10 hours × $30 = $300/month.
  7. Include other benefits. These might include faster onboarding (new hires productive sooner), reduced training time, or improved customer satisfaction leading to retained revenue. Assign a conservative dollar value to each if possible—otherwise, note them as qualitative benefits.
  8. Total the monthly benefits. Add time savings, error reduction, and any other quantified benefits to get your total monthly benefit.
  9. Calculate the total cost of ownership (TCO). Include one-time development costs, ongoing hosting/subscription fees, maintenance (typically 15-20% of development cost per year), and internal support time. Spread these over a 3-year period for a realistic view.
  10. Compute ROI. Use the formula: (Total benefits over 3 years − Total costs over 3 years) ÷ Total costs × 100 = ROI percentage. A positive ROI means the software pays for itself; a negative ROI means it doesn’t.
  11. Present the result. Show the ROI as a percentage and also as a payback period (total cost ÷ monthly benefit = months to break even). Include the assumptions you made so stakeholders can adjust them.

Common Mistakes

  • Ignoring hidden costs: Forgetting to include training time, data migration, or the cost of the team’s time during implementation. These can be significant.
  • Overestimating time savings: Assuming the software will eliminate 100% of a task when it might only reduce it. Always use realistic, conservative estimates.
  • Using gross salary instead of fully loaded cost: The true cost per hour includes benefits, taxes, and overhead—often 1.3-1.5× the base salary.
  • Not accounting for ongoing maintenance: Custom software needs updates, bug fixes, and support. Skipping these makes ROI look better than it is.
  • Measuring only one metric: Focusing solely on time saved and missing error reduction or improved employee satisfaction, which can be equally valuable.

Tips

  • Involve the actual employees who do the workflow when estimating baseline times—they know the real bottlenecks.
  • Use a range: Calculate ROI with best-case and worst-case scenarios to see how sensitive the result is to your assumptions.
  • Track post-implementation data: After the software goes live, measure actual time savings and compare to your estimates. This validates your ROI and helps with future projects.
  • Consider intangible benefits: If you can’t put a dollar value on them, list them separately (e.g., “reduced employee burnout”)—they strengthen the case even if not in the formula.
  • Re-evaluate annually: Costs and benefits change. Update your ROI calculation each year to ensure the software is still worth it.

Troubleshooting

If your ROI is negative: Re-examine your assumptions. Are you overestimating costs or underestimating benefits? Sometimes the software has a longer payback period than 3 years—extend the timeframe if the software will last longer. Also consider whether the software can be used for other workflows to spread the cost.

If you can’t get reliable baseline data: Run a small pilot or time study for a week to gather real numbers. If that’s not possible, use industry benchmarks from similar companies, but clearly note they are estimates.

If stakeholders question the numbers: Show your work clearly, including every formula and assumption. Be transparent about what you’ve estimated vs. measured. Offer to adjust the calculation with their inputs.

If the software is already built and you’re measuring after the fact: Use actual costs and actual time savings observed since launch. Compare against the pre-implementation baseline you should have recorded—if you didn’t, reconstruct it from logs or employee memory.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How long should I use as the ROI period?
A: Typically 3-5 years for custom software, since that’s the expected lifespan before major rework. Shorter periods are fine if the technology is likely to change soon.

Q: What if the software saves time but employees use the extra time for non-productive tasks?
A: That’s a management issue, not an ROI issue. The potential savings are real; whether you capture them depends on how you redeploy the freed-up time. In your ROI, you can assume a percentage (e.g., 70%) of saved time is actually productive.

Q: Can I include employee satisfaction as a benefit?
A: Yes, but it’s hard to quantify. You could use a survey to measure engagement before and after, then tie improved retention to reduced hiring costs (which you can estimate).

Q: How do I handle the cost of my own time in the calculation?
A: Your time spent managing the project is a real cost. Estimate the hours you and your team spend on requirements, testing, and project management, and include them at your hourly rate.

Q: Is ROI the only metric I should look at?
A: No. Also consider net present value (NPV) for large projects, and payback period. ROI is a good starting point, but NPV accounts for the time value of money, which matters for multi-year projects.

Q: What if the software is a complete failure?
A: That’s a risk. To mitigate, build in milestones and checkpoints during development. If it fails, you can still learn from the process and apply those lessons to future projects—though that’s not a financial return.

Related

General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.

More in this bed

The whole Tech How-To bed →