If your external hard drive is running slowly on your Mac, the fix usually involves checking the connection type, cable, and file system, then optimizing how the drive is formatted and used. This guide walks you through the most common causes and the step-by-step fixes that restore full speed.
Why Your External Drive Feels Slow
External hard drives connected to a Mac can slow down for several reasons. The most common are a USB 2.0 connection being used instead of USB 3.0 or Thunderbolt, a failing or low-quality cable, a drive formatted with the wrong file system (like NTFS without proper support), or the drive being nearly full. Background tasks like Time Machine backups or Spotlight indexing can also hammer the drive, making every file operation feel sluggish. Less often, the drive itself may be failing, or the Mac’s power management is putting the drive to sleep too aggressively.
Check the Cable and Port First
Before changing any settings, verify the physical connection. Many external drives ship with a USB 3.0 cable, but if you plug it into a USB 2.0 port (or use an older cable), you’ll be stuck at 480 Mbps instead of 5 Gbps or faster. Here’s what to do:
- Unplug the drive and try a different port on your Mac, preferably one that supports USB 3.0 or Thunderbolt (often marked with a “SS” or a lightning bolt icon).
- Swap the cable with a known-good one, ideally the one that came with the drive. Short, thick cables carry data more reliably than long, thin ones.
- If you’re using a USB hub, connect the drive directly to the Mac. Hubs, especially unpowered ones, can starve the drive of power and cause slowdowns or disconnects.
After reconnecting, check the connection speed in System Information (hold Option and click the Apple menu → System Information → USB or Thunderbolt). If it shows “Up to 480 Mb/sec,” you’re on USB 2.0. Look for “Up to 5 Gb/sec” or higher.
File System Matters: APFS vs. exFAT vs. NTFS
The format of your drive dramatically affects performance and compatibility. macOS natively reads and writes to APFS (Apple File System) and HFS+ (Mac OS Extended). If your drive is formatted as NTFS (Windows default), macOS can only read it by default—writing is disabled unless you install third-party software like Paragon NTFS or use the built-in (but hidden) experimental NTFS write support. That workaround is slow and unreliable. exFAT works well on both Mac and Windows, but it lacks journaling, so it can be slower at metadata operations and more prone to corruption if unplugged improperly.
For best performance on a Mac-only drive, reformat to APFS (for SSDs) or Mac OS Extended (Journaled) for traditional spinning hard drives. If you need cross-platform compatibility, exFAT is the best compromise, but expect slightly slower performance than native formats. Reformatting erases all data, so back up first.
Reformat the Drive (If Needed)
If you decide to reformat, use Disk Utility (found in /Applications/Utilities/). Here’s the safe way:
- Back up any data on the drive to another location.
- Open Disk Utility, select the drive in the sidebar (not the volume underneath it), and click “Erase.”
- Choose a name, then set Format to “APFS” (for SSDs) or “Mac OS Extended (Journaled)” for spinning drives. For cross-platform, choose “exFAT.”
- Click “Erase.” Wait for it to finish, then re-mount the drive.
After reformatting, the drive will be clean and fast. If it was previously formatted as NTFS, this often resolves the slowness immediately.
Free Up Space and Check Health
A nearly full drive is a slow drive. Both HDDs and SSDs slow down as they fill up. For traditional hard drives, the outer tracks (which hold the first data written) are faster than inner tracks. If your drive is over 90% full, delete files or move them elsewhere. Also, run First Aid in Disk Utility to check for file system errors:
- Open Disk Utility, select the drive, and click “First Aid” → “Run.”
- If it finds errors, it will attempt to repair them. This can take a while on a large drive.
If the drive is making clicking noises, is extremely hot, or shows up as “not recognized” intermittently, it may be failing. Back up immediately and consider replacing it.
Disable Spotlight Indexing for That Drive
Spotlight constantly indexes files on connected drives. If you have a large external drive, indexing can consume significant CPU and I/O, making the drive feel slow, especially when you first connect it. To turn off indexing for a specific drive:
- Open System Settings → Spotlight → Spotlight Privacy.
- Click the + button and add your external drive to the list.
- Spotlight will stop indexing that drive. You can re-enable it later by removing it from the list.
This doesn’t delete any files; it just prevents Spotlight from scanning them. If you later search for files on that drive, they won’t appear in Spotlight results until you re-enable indexing.
Check for Time Machine or Other Background Activity
Time Machine backups can saturate an external drive for minutes or hours, especially if it’s the backup destination. If your drive is the Time Machine destination, check if a backup is running (menu bar icon spinning). You can pause backups temporarily. Also, other apps like antivirus, cloud sync (Dropbox, Google Drive), or media servers (Plex) might be scanning or writing to the drive. Quit these apps and see if speed improves.
When to Consider an SSD or a Different Connection
If your external drive is a traditional spinning hard drive (HDD), its maximum sustained transfer speed is typically around 150-200 MB/s. Over USB 3.0, that’s fine. But if you’re doing heavy video editing or large file transfers, an SSD will be significantly faster—often 500 MB/s to over 1 GB/s. If you’re using an SSD but it’s still slow, make sure it’s connected via USB 3.1 Gen 2 (10 Gbps) or Thunderbolt 3/4 for full speed. Also, check if the drive is using a SATA III connection internally; some enclosures are limited to SATA II (3 Gbps).
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is my external hard drive so slow on my Mac but fast on Windows?
Most likely the drive is formatted as NTFS. macOS reads NTFS natively but writes only through an unoptimized, hidden driver that is extremely slow. Reformat to exFAT (if you need Windows compatibility) or APFS (Mac-only) to get full write speeds.
Can a bad USB cable cause slow transfer speeds?
Yes. A damaged or low-quality cable can drop the connection from USB 3.0 to USB 2.0 speeds, or cause intermittent disconnects. Try a different, shorter cable to see if the speed improves.
How do I check if my external drive is failing?
Use Disk Utility’s First Aid to check the file system, and listen for unusual clicking or grinding noises. You can also use third-party tools like DriveDx or smartctl (via Terminal) to check S.M.A.R.T. status, but those are not built into macOS. If you see “S.M.A.R.T. status: Failing,” back up immediately.
Does formatting a drive as APFS make it faster than Mac OS Extended?
For SSDs, yes—APFS is optimized for flash storage and supports TRIM. For traditional hard drives, APFS can sometimes be slightly slower due to its copy-on-write metadata handling. Mac OS Extended (Journaled) is a safe choice for HDDs.
Why does my external drive slow down after being idle?
macOS spins down external HDDs after a period of inactivity to save power. When you access it again, it takes a few seconds to spin up. This is normal. You can disable sleep for the drive in System Settings → Battery (or Energy Saver) by unchecking “Put hard disks to sleep when possible.”
Is it safe to disconnect an external drive without ejecting?
No. Always eject the drive (right-click → Eject) or drag it to the Trash before unplugging. If you don’t, data may be corrupted, especially if the drive is writing. If you get a “Disk Not Ejected Properly” warning, it’s a sign you risk data loss.
Related
General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this bed
- Set a Google Play Budget & Stop Accidental Purchases
- Destiny 2 Error Code Anteater: Fixes & Causes
- View Android Photos on Chromebook: Step-by-Step
- Fix Windows Could Not Prepare the Computer to Boot
- Windows 11 Security Settings: Best Config Guide
- Install Custom Recovery on Samsung Galaxy Trend