sodcalculator

10 Tech How-To

Microsoft Authenticator vs Google Authenticator

Guide 10-54106 · Updated · Step by step

The main difference between Microsoft Authenticator and Google Authenticator is that Microsoft Authenticator offers cloud backup, multi-device sync, and a built-in password manager, while Google Authenticator stores codes only on the device and now offers optional cloud sync. Both apps generate time-based one-time passcodes (TOTP) for two-factor authentication (2FA), but they differ in account recovery, platform integration, and how they handle multiple devices.

Background: Why You Need an Authenticator App

Two-factor authentication adds a second layer of security beyond your password. Instead of just entering a password, you also provide a code that changes every 30 seconds. Authenticator apps generate these codes locally using a shared secret, so they work even without an internet connection. SMS-based codes are vulnerable to SIM-swapping and interception, which is why security experts recommend app-based TOTP. Both Microsoft and Google offer free apps that do this, but they were built with different philosophies: Google Authenticator was designed as a simple, offline code generator, while Microsoft Authenticator evolved into a broader identity management tool.

How Each App Works

Both apps use the same underlying TOTP algorithm (RFC 6238). When you enable 2FA on a service, it gives you a QR code or a secret key. You scan that code with the authenticator app, and the app stores the secret. Every 30 seconds, it combines the secret with the current time to produce a 6-digit code. The server does the same calculation, so the codes match.

  • Google Authenticator: Simple and minimal. You scan a QR code, and the app immediately shows a 6-digit code. There is no account creation, no password, and no backup by default. If you lose your phone, you lose access to all your 2FA codes unless you saved the backup keys.
  • Microsoft Authenticator: Requires you to sign in with a Microsoft account (or a work/school account) to use cloud backup. It can also approve sign-in requests with a simple tap (push notifications) for Microsoft accounts, and it supports passwordless login for Microsoft services. For non-Microsoft sites, it still generates TOTP codes like Google Authenticator.

Key Differences at a Glance

Here is a direct comparison of the most important features:

Feature Microsoft Authenticator Google Authenticator
Cloud backup Yes (with Microsoft account) Optional (since 2023, with Google account)
Multi-device sync Yes, codes sync across devices Yes, but setup requires QR scan on new device
Push approval for Microsoft/Google accounts Yes (Microsoft, Azure AD) Yes (Google accounts only)
Password manager Built-in (for Microsoft account users) No
Platform support Android, iOS, Windows Phone (legacy) Android, iOS
Open-source No Yes (code on GitHub)
Account recovery Easier with cloud backup Manual, requires backup codes

Note that Google Authenticator’s cloud sync is not enabled by default for everyone; you must update the app and then explicitly turn it on. Microsoft Authenticator requires a Microsoft account to use backup, which some users may not want.

How to Choose Between Them

Your choice depends on your ecosystem and your needs:

  • Use Microsoft Authenticator if: you primarily use Microsoft services (Outlook, Office 365, Azure), want cloud backup and easy recovery, or want push notifications for Microsoft accounts. It also works with any TOTP-based service, so you can use it for Google, Facebook, etc.
  • Use Google Authenticator if: you prefer a minimal, no-account app, are concerned about privacy (no Microsoft account required), or want an open-source solution. It’s also perfectly fine for any TOTP service, including Microsoft.

Both apps are free and have no ads. If you use both Microsoft and Google services heavily, you might end up using both apps, but that’s not necessary—each can handle all your TOTP codes.

Common Problems and Misconceptions

“I lost my phone and my codes are gone.” This is the biggest issue with Google Authenticator without backup. If you didn’t save backup codes or the secret key, you’ll need to use recovery codes from each service, which can be a hassle. Microsoft Authenticator’s cloud backup solves this, but it requires you to have signed in with a Microsoft account before losing the device.

“The codes don’t match.” This usually happens when your device’s time is off. Both apps rely on your phone’s clock. Go to settings and enable automatic time sync. Also, if you’re traveling across time zones, the app should still work because it uses UTC, but a manual time setting can break it.

“I can’t transfer my codes to a new phone.” Google Authenticator now has a transfer feature that shows a QR code on the old phone, which you scan with the new phone. Microsoft Authenticator lets you restore from backup. If you didn’t set up either, you’ll have to re-add each account manually.

“Is it safe to store all my codes in one app?” Yes, it’s generally safe because the secrets are stored encrypted on your device. The risk is losing the device, so always save backup codes or enable cloud backup.

Security and Privacy Considerations

Both apps store TOTP secrets locally, but Microsoft Authenticator sends your secrets to Microsoft’s cloud if you enable backup. Microsoft encrypts this data and uses it only for recovery, but some privacy-conscious users prefer to keep everything offline with Google Authenticator (unless you enable its cloud sync). Google Authenticator is open-source, meaning anyone can audit the code, which is a plus for transparency. Microsoft Authenticator is closed-source but undergoes regular security audits.

Another difference: Microsoft Authenticator can act as a passwordless sign-in for Microsoft accounts, which is more secure than passwords alone. Google Authenticator does not offer passwordless login; it only generates TOTP codes.

Alternatives Worth Considering

If neither app feels right, there are other TOTP authenticators:

  • Authy: Offers cloud backup and multi-device sync, with a master password. Works on desktop too.
  • 1Password or Bitwarden: Password managers that also store TOTP codes, so you have everything in one place.
  • Aegis Authenticator: Open-source, Android-only, with local encrypted backups.

These alternatives often provide more control over backups and are worth trying if you want features beyond what the two big apps offer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Microsoft Authenticator for Google accounts?

Yes, Microsoft Authenticator supports any TOTP-based service. You can scan the QR code from Google’s 2FA setup and it will generate codes just like Google Authenticator would.

Can I use Google Authenticator for Microsoft accounts?

Yes, Microsoft allows you to use any authenticator app for personal accounts. During setup, choose “I want to use a different authenticator app” and scan the QR code with Google Authenticator.

Which app is more secure?

Both are considered secure, but Microsoft Authenticator has an edge because it supports push approval (which is phishing-resistant) for Microsoft accounts, and it can be set up with a recovery method. Google Authenticator is open-source, which some users trust more. The main security risk is losing your phone, which is mitigated by backup options.

Do I need an account to use these apps?

Google Authenticator requires no account at all—you just install and use it. Microsoft Authenticator can be used without an account, but you’ll lose cloud backup and push notifications. To get those features, you need to sign in with a Microsoft account.

Can I have the same code on two phones?

Yes, with Microsoft Authenticator you can restore your backup on a second phone and have the same codes. With Google Authenticator, you can use the transfer feature to move codes, but it’s not designed for simultaneous use on two devices. For true multi-device use, consider Authy.

What happens if I uninstall the app?

If you uninstall without backing up, you lose all your TOTP secrets. You’ll need to re-enable 2FA on each service using backup codes. With Microsoft Authenticator, you can reinstall and restore from cloud backup if you had it enabled. Google Authenticator now also offers cloud sync, but it must be turned on before uninstalling.

Related

General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.

More in this bed

The whole Tech How-To bed →